mobile-layout-image

1ST WAVE OF THE PANDEMIC (FEB TO MAY 2020)

LOWMEDIUMHIGH

In the map above, Europe is grouped in three major areas described by the level of the death per million index. During the first wave of the pandemic and specifically during the months of February 2020 to May 2020, Western Europe was majorly hit by COVID-19 and presents the higher death per million indices. Taking into account the socioeconomic status of the countries, as well as the ways the countries responded with special measures to the pandemic, we can suggest some explanations for these observations.

The table below presents the data concerning the first COVID-19 case date for each country, the date each country reached 100 cases, the days elapsed between these two dates and finally the dates elapsed between the 100 cases date and the date lockdown measures were imposed. We notice that the virus first arrived in prosperous countries with the highest numbers of arrivals in their airports.

For example, in Belgium the first COVID-19 case was recorded on the 4rth of February 2020, while many neighboring countries took more than twenty days to record the first case. We can also see that in most of the countries in the red group, more than a month passed before they reached one hundred (100) cases. During this period, most probably the virus achieved a substantial spread before any special measures were even considered.

In the rest of countries where the virus arrived with delay, there was enough time for awareness and preparation. As a consequence, many of these countries proceeded with lockdowns without any delay and prevented the spread of the virus.

CountryDate of
First Case
Days to
100th Cases
Date of
100th Case
Date of
Lockdown
Days to Lock down
from 100th Case
France25/1/20201/3/20203616/3/202015
Germany28/1/20201/3/20203321/3/202020
Italy31/1/202024/2/2020248/3/202013
Russia1/2/202018/3/20204628/3/202010
Spain1/2/20202/3/20203013/3/202011
United Kingdom1/2/20204/3/20203224/3/202020
Belgium4/2/20205/3/20203018/3/202013
Sweden5/2/20207/3/202031  
Austria26/2/20209/3/20201216/3/20207
Croatia26/2/202020/3/20202318/4/202029
Switzerland26/2/20207/3/20201023/3/202016
Denmark27/2/202010/3/20201218/3/20208
Greece27/2/202013/3/20201523/3/202010
North Macedonia27/2/202023/3/2020254/6/202073
Norway27/2/20207/3/20209  
Romania27/2/202015/3/20201730/3/202015
Belarus28/2/202031/3/202032  
Estonia28/2/202015/3/20201630/3/202015
Lithuania28/2/202022/3/20202327/5/202066
Netherlands28/2/20207/3/20208  
Iceland29/2/202013/3/202013  
Ireland1/3/202015/3/20201428/3/202013
Luxembourg1/3/202018/3/20201716/3/2020-2
Czechia2/3/202013/3/20201116/3/20203
Latvia3/3/202021/3/202018  
Portugal3/3/202014/3/2020113/4/202020
Poland4/3/202015/3/20201124/3/20209
Ukraine4/3/202026/3/20202215/3/2020-11
Hungary5/3/202021/3/20201617/3/2020-4
Liechtenstein5/3/202021/8/2020169  
Slovenia5/3/202014/3/2020919/3/20205
Bosnia and Herzegovina6/3/202023/3/202017  
Malta7/3/202023/3/202016  
Serbia7/3/202020/3/2020132/4/202013
Slovakia7/3/202019/3/2020128/4/202020
Bulgaria8/3/202020/3/20201213/3/2020-7
Moldova8/3/202024/3/2020168/4/202015
Albania9/3/202024/3/2020152/4/20209
Cyprus10/3/202024/3/20201424/3/20200

Prosperity Index 2019

Western EuropeEastern Europe0102030405060708090

Airport Passengers 2019 (Million)

020406080100120140160180200Inc. BergamoWestern EuropeEastern Europe

Prosperous countries, which in most cases have a high mobility in their airports, were among the first to be hit by the pandemic, for one more reason. They probably delayed their decisions on taking aggressive measures against COVID-19, under the fear that such decisions could slow down their economies. This ambivalence may resulted in a high spread of the virus with dramatic results.

Population Density

Western EuropeEastern Europe0100200300400500600

The population density is another factor working in favor of the spread of the virus, and although regional density within a country is a more appropriate index, the total country population density helps the understanding of the European incidence differentiation. For example, Scandinavian and Baltic countries having lower population density are among medium and lower hit countries. While countries of Western Europe with high population density such as The Netherlands, Belgium or United Kingdom, were highly hit by the pandemic.

Health System Index 2019

Western EuropeEastern Europe0102030405060708090Index> 80

ICU Beds per 100.000 Pop

Western EuropeEastern Europe0510152025303540

The health systems of the western European countries are usually of higher quality compared to the health systems of the eastern European countries, as the above two graphs demonstrate. This situation, combined with the incidents in Italy – Bergamo, was most probably another reason that led eastern European countries to adopt aggressive measures against COVID-19, faster that their western partners.

COVID-19 Cases Age Distribution

Europe0 - 1920 - 2930 - 3940 - 4950 - 5960 - 6970 - 7980 +
Western Europe2%8%10%13%17%13%13%25%
Eastern Europe6%9%15%21%21%15%8%5%

There is a significant difference in the age distribution of COVID-19 cases between western and eastern European countries. More than 50% of COVID-19 cases in western European countries fall in the 60+ years segment, with 25% in the 80+ years segment. On the contrary, only 28% of COVID-19 cases fall in the 60+ years segment, in the eastern European countries.

Countries – Age Statistics

CountryPop
Median Age
Pop Age
> 70 years %
Cases
Med Age
Deaths
Med Age
Cases
> 70 years %
Cases Med Age
vs Pop Age
Deaths Med Age
vs Pop Age
Cases > 70 years %
vs
Pop Age > 70 years %
Mortality %
United Kingdom40,512,561,580,542,41,5191,9873,38114,7%
Belgium41,412,862,284,042,71,5022,0293,32616,0%
Netherlands42,611,960,282,238,01,4131,9293,19812,9%
France41,413,154,084,038,01,3042,0292,90519,0%
Spain42,713,860,482,637,11,4141,9342,68911,3%
Italy45,516,262,081,540,01,3631,7912,46214,3%
Sweden41,213,455,082,029,81,3361,992,21812,1%
Switzerland42,412,651,985,422,81,2242,0141,8075,4%
Portugal42,214,949,184,921,91,1642,0121,4674,3%
Estonia42,713,552,1 19,51,219 1,4423,4%
Denmark42,212,347,9 17,31,134 1,4044,9%
Greece44,514,547,377,020,01,0621,7311,3776,0%
Moldova36,77,049,2 8,81,341 1,2653,6%
Germany47,116,049,682,620,01,0531,754;1,2534,6%
Norway39,210,845,2 12,91,153 1,1952,8%
Romania41,111,748,4 13,31,117 1,1366,5%
Finland42,513,343,0 12,1;1,012 0,9094,6%
Latvia43,614,143,4 12,80,995 0,9022,3%

To better understand the population age effect on COVID-19 incidences and deaths by country, we can examine the above table summary data. In the blue area of the table, we see countries that have a high median age in their COVID-19 cases, 55+ years and over. The ratio of %Cases 70 years over %Population Age>70 years in these countries, is above 2.2 demonstrating that COVID-19 hit twice as much the elderly population. As a consequence, to this, we note a high mortality rate in these countries. In contrast Germany, despite the fact that it has the highest median age population, we note a lower median age of COVID-19 cases (50 years vs 55+) and a ratio of 1.2, which leads to a much lower mortality rate (4.6% as compared to over 12% in the countries in the blue area of the table). It is interesting to understand the potential factors behind this difference.

Care Home Bed per 1000 Pop

012345678910111213Western EuropeEastern Europe

The above graph demonstrates the fact that many countries of the blue area of the previous table have significantly higher number of elderly people care homes, which were severely hit by the COVID-19 pandemic as we will see in the table below. Most of these countries did not protect early enough these elderly people care facilities, with the exception of Germany, which probably explains the demonstrated difference in the mortality rates.

In the table below we can see that almost 50% of the COVID 19 deaths happened in elderly people care facilities.

CountryReport dateConfirmed COVID-19 Cases in LTCF residentsCOVID-19-related Deaths in LTCF residentsTotal COVID-19 Deaths% of all COVID-19 Deaths in LTCF in the country
Belgium25 May5,7344,7359,31251%
France29 May74,40214,11328,53950%
Germany25 May15,7573,1388,25738%
Ireland25 May6,3928111,35460%
Norway25 May Unknown13923559%
Netherlands19 May9,4741,7795,69431%
Spain 25 MayUnknown19,06628,75266%
Sweden18 May2,8661,7773,66149%
UK – England & Wales15 MayUnknown11,65345,22626%
UK – Scotland17 May5,6521,6233,54646%

The following graph demonstrates the average reduction of mobility during the first wave of the pandemic (March to May 2020) attributed to the lockdown policies applied by most of the European countries. Most European countries reduced their population mobility over 50%. Italy, Spain, France, UK, Belgium demonstrate some of the highest reduction rates of mobility but failed to restrain the first wave of pandemic. We note that Germany had a reduction of population mobility of 40%.

Avg Mobility Mar-May

ItalySpainGermanyAustriaRomaniaBelgiumLithuaniaPortugalSwedenGreeceFinlandSloveniaNetherlandsIrelandUnited KingdomDenmarkPolandNorwayRussiaSlovakiaLatviaSwitzerlandCzechiaFranceBulgariaHungaryEstoniaCroatiaLuxembourg0-10-20-30-40-50-60-70-80-90UkraineMoldovaBosnia and HerzegovinaBelarusSerbiaNorth MacedoniaMalta

Cases per 1M vs Deaths per 1M (Feb-May)

BelgiumSpainUnited KingdomItalySwedenFranceNetherlandsIrelandSwitzerlandLuxembourgPortugalGermanyDenmarkAustriaMoldovaRomaniaNorth MacedoniaFinlandHungarySloveniaEstoniaBosnia and HerzegovinaNorwaySerbiaRussiaCzechiaIcelandPolandLiechtensteinCroatiaLithuaniaBelarusBulgariaCyprusMaltaKosovoGreeceUkraineMontenegroLatviaAlbaniaSlovakia-100010020030040050060070080001000200030004000500060007000Deaths per 1M pop (Feb - May) Cases per 1M (Feb - May)

In most countries, there is an analogy between cases and deaths per million. The Western European countries, such us Belgium, Spain, Italy, UK etc present the highest number of cases and deaths per million, with Germany being the odd one out with much lower numbers of cases and deaths per million. Belarus, on the other hand demonstrate a significantly lower number of deaths per million, given their high number of cases per million.